As the Denver Broncos gear up for the 2024 NFL season, one of the more intriguing roster battles is for the backup quarterback position. The battle between Zach Wilson and Jarrett Stidham for the backup role has caught the attention of fans and analysts alike. Given Bo Nix’s performance against the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday, most are expecting him to be named the starter for week one in the coming weeks. With this, it’s worth making the case for why Zach Wilson should be the Broncos’ choice for the backup role and releasing/trading Jarrett Stidham.
Upside and Potential
When evaluating quarterbacks, potential is a critical factor, and in this regard, Zach Wilson offers a higher ceiling than Jarrett Stidham. Despite his struggles with the New York Jets, Wilson’s physical tools are impressive. His arm strength, mobility, and ability to make throws on the run are qualities that can be developed into a more consistent skill set. Stidham, on the other hand, has shown flashes of competence but lacks the same level of high-end potential. Investing in a quarterback like Wilson, who has demonstrated the ability to make spectacular plays, could pay off significantly if he harnesses his skills and matures into a reliable option.
Experience in a High-Pressure Environment
Zach Wilson’s experience as a starting quarterback with the Jets provided him with valuable game-time under pressure. Playing in a big market like New York, where expectations and scrutiny are high, Wilson has faced intense situations and learned to handle adversity. While he may have had some rough patches, the experience he gained dealing with the high stakes is invaluable. Stidham has had limited starting opportunities and hasn’t faced the same level of scrutiny, which means Wilson’s experience in high-pressure environments could be crucial if he’s called upon to step in during a critical moment.
Mobility and Playmaking Ability
In today’s NFL, mobility is a significant asset for a quarterback. Zach Wilson’s ability to extend plays with his legs and make off-schedule throws adds an element of unpredictability to an offense. While Bo Nix is known for his more than adequate mobility, having a backup who can also create plays on the move provides a seamless transition in case of injury. Stidham, although competent, lacks the same dynamic playmaking ability. Wilson’s athleticism could be what the Broncos would need in the chance of injury to Nix.
Development and Growth Potential
One of the key aspects of building a successful team is player development. Zach Wilson is still young and has room to grow. With the right coaching and development, he could become a much improved player. Sean Payton has a reputation for developing talent, having worked with Tony Romo, Kerry Collins, and furthering the development of Jameis Winston (this after Winston’s 30 interception year in Tampa Bay). Stidham, while experienced, is at a point where he may have reached his developmental peak. Investing in Wilson allows the Broncos to tap into his potential and see if he can become a valuable asset in the long run.
Future Planning
Looking ahead, having a backup with a higher ceiling like Zach Wilson could align with the Broncos’ long term plans. If Wilson shows promise and develops into a reliable backup, he could become a trade asset or even a future starter. Stidham, in contrast, might not offer the same long term benefits. By choosing Wilson as the backup, the Broncos can evaluate his potential and decide on his future with the team, while also preparing for any potential shifts in the quarterback landscape.
